Blog

Home | Blog | Dropped plate amounts to negligence
Dropped plate amounts to negligence
  January 23, 2013|  0 comments|  By jj

Newark, N.J. – A seafood restaurant guest injured by flying shards of glass from a dropped plate need not prove waiter negligence in oder to recover for damage to his corneas, a federal judge ruled on January 8.
broken-plate_grey-300x199Plaintiff Darryl Clark moved for summary judgment under the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, which allows an inference of liability if an incident “bespeaks negligence,” the injuring instrument was under the defendants’s control and there’s no indication that plaintiff contributed to the injury.

U.S. Districts Judge Freda Wolfson agreed, ruling, “This is not a difficult case.” She said it is “axiomatic that a server in a restaurant has a duty not to drop a plate on the table in front of pantrons, particularly a breakable plate.”

source: National Law Journal (Print)

The Law Offices of Timothy J. Ryan and Associates defend the rights of the injured, if you have been injured please contact us for a free consultation 

Search
Contact form

Click Here or Call (714)-898-4444 to Obtain Your Free Confidential Case Evaluation.